Signed, sealed… Secured? – When is a Mortgagee Secured? - JHK Legal Commercial Lawyers

15 November 2026

Signed, sealed… Secured? – When is a Mortgagee Secured?

Written by Craig Reynolds

The Transfer of Land Act 1958 (Vic) (TLA) provides that a mortgagee’s interest pursuant to a mortgage over real property will become indefeasible only upon registration of that interest on the title for the land.[1]

Indefeasibility provides that the mortgage will encumber the land unless the mortgagee committed fraud to obtain the mortgage or the mortgagee was aware of, or recklessly indifferent to, such fraud.[2]

This raises the question, if indefeasibility is only afforded upon registration, does that mean until registration the mortgagee does not hold an enforceable mortgage or binding security over the land?

This article will focus on these questions within the context of the laws in Victoria and ultimately conclude that provided there is:

  • A debt or obligation secured by the land; and
  • The landowner:
    • Executes a mortgage instrument for the land; or
    • Acts in a way evidencing an express intention to create a binding security interest over the land;

the mortgagee will be provided the security afforded by a mortgage even if the mortgage is not registered, albeit the rights of enforcement differ between a registered and unregistered mortgage.

What is a Mortgage?

The general definition of what a mortgage is, was originally conceived in Santley v. Wilde (1899) 2 Ch 474, at p 474, being defined as:

“a mortgage is a conveyance of land or an assignment of chattels as a security for the payment of a debt or the discharge of some other obligation for which it is given”

This definition was adopted by the High Court of Australia with the High Court adding that that such conveyance may be “either a conveyance in equity or at law” and “although a mortgage usually secures a money debt, it does not always do so”.[3]

The essential part of a mortgage is that if the mortgagor defaults on their debt or obligation, the mortgagee’s right to the mortgaged property becomes absolute at law, but in equity the mortgagor is entitled to redeem the property on discharging the debt or obligation or, if the property is sold, to any surplus that remains.[4]

What Creates a Mortgage?

A legal mortgage arises upon an instrument in the approved form being registered on the folio of the land pursuant to the provisions of the TLA. Meaning, a legal mortgage can only be created upon its registration on folio for the land.[5]

But a legal mortgage is not the only type of mortgage; a mortgage can also be created in equity.

Circumstances where the courts have established an equitable mortgage include:

  • A binding promise for the delivery of a certificate of title as security to cause the mortgagee to advance funds on that promise.[6]
  • A loan agreement being executed but the mortgage instrument was not annexed to the agreement was not signed, despite follow up by the mortgagee.[7]
  • The deposit of two certificates of title with a mortgage broker as security for a debt owed to the mortgagee.[8]
  • The deposit of title by a party that was not a mortgagor in circumstances where the mortgagor had no direct dealings with the mortgagee but intended to create a security for a third party’s debt.[9]
  • The execution of a mortgage instrument which was not registered.[10]

What is critical for the creation of an equitable mortgage is a binding promise from which consideration flows[11] for the creation of a security interest over the relevant land.[12]

Why Registration Matters

Not only does registration of a mortgage provide the mortgagee indefeasibility as to its interest, but it also provides mechanisms of enforcement under the TLA that may not necessarily require the intervention of the court.[13]

By contrast, an equitable mortgage is not recognised by the TLA and therefore any enforcement requires an order from the court that either:

  • Registers the mortgage (if it complies with the TLA); or
  • Enables the sale of land and realisation of proceeds by the mortgagee.

Outside of enforcement, failure to register a mortgage or otherwise provide notice that an equitable mortgage is held may result in the interest of the mortgagee falling behind other interest holders, including caveators.

JHK Legal has already explored priority and postponing conduct and therefore this article will not expand on this principle further.[14]

Indefeasible Mortgage but Defeasible Debt

While indefeasibility will protect a mortgagee’s mortgage if it is not deemed to have committed or been reckless as to fraud, such protection may preserve a mortgage that has no debt assigned to it.

Some mortgagees have adopted an all-monies approach to the terms of their mortgage, meaning that the debt that attaches to the mortgage is linked with another document that does not form part of the mortgage, such as a loan agreement.

This all-monies approach has the benefit of enabling the mortgagee to vary the debt amount owed more easily than having to amend a mortgage. However, in cases of fraud, this ease could be a double-edged sword.

Indefeasibility only attaches to the covenant for payment under the mortgage,[15] meaning that if there is no debt specified in the mortgage and rather it is defined by a separate document that was also tainted by forgery, then, at least in Victoria, the document creating the debt falls away. Therefore, the mortgage secures no debt and ultimately fails.[16]

 Where to From Here?

While an equitable mortgage is almost certainly created when a mortgage instrument is executed, it does not receive the benefit of indefeasibility until registered.

What is clear is that an equitable mortgage can be created in many circumstances. However, the cost and risk associated with utilising equity to secure or enforce a debt compared to having an indefeasible mortgage appear to be a recipe for disaster.

Obviously, the most effective way for a mortgagee to secure its interest and priority over other parties, is to register its mortgage as soon as practicable after reasonable steps have been taken to identify the mortgagor and note the debt that attaches to the mortgage in the terms of the mortgage itself.

If a mortgagee does not intend to register its mortgage for whatever reason, the mortgagee must ensure that it notifies other potential creditors of its interest as mortgagee so as to preserve its priority and that it is aware of the additional costs and risks of relying on an equitable mortgage.


[1] TLA s 42 (1)

[2] See Macquarie Bank Ltd v Sixty-Fourth Throne Pty Ltd [1998] 3 VR 133 for further information regarding fraud and indefeasibility, in this case the court extensively considered the principles of a mortgage that was forged.

[3] Handevel Pty. Ltd. v. Comptroller of Stamps (VICT.) (1985) 157 CLR 177 [12]

[4] Beconwood Securities Pty Ltd and Another v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd and Others (2008) 246 ALR 361 [46]

[5] TLA s 40

[6] Pico Holdings Inc v Wave Vistas Pty Ltd [2005] HCA 13; 79 ALJR 825

[7] Cheetham v 805 Archer Road Pty Ltd (in liq) [2015] VSC 96

[8] Helimount Pty Ltd (in liq) v Web Wealth Pty Ltd [2007] FCA 1936

[9] Theodore v Mistford Pty Ltd [2005] HCA 45; 221 CLR 612

[10] Roberts Gray Pty Ltd (T/As Roberts Gray Lawyers) v Brunner [2021] VSC 76

[11] Pico Holdings Inc v Wave Vistas Pty Ltd [2005] HCA 13; 79 ALJR 825 [66]

[12] Ibid [68]

[13] For further information regarding the powers afforded to a mortgagee holding a valid legal mortgage please see JHK Legal’s article entitled “Mortgagee power of sale” dated 9 July 2026 by Chelsea Lo Giudice.

[14] For further information regarding postponing conduct see the following JHK Legal articles:

  •  “Priority between Competing Equitable Interests in Real Property and how best to address the risk of losing priority in New South Wales” dated 30 March 2025 by Alexander Demlakian.
  • “Caveats – Limitations They Have and Pose” dated 15 October 2025 by Sarah Jones.

[15] Perpetual Trustees Victoria Ltd v Xiao Hui Ying [2015] VSC 21 [83]

[16] Ibid [84]